Selected Decisions of Speaker Lucien Lamoureux 1966 – 1974
Routine Proceedings / Motions
Committee report
Journals pp. 636-7
Debates p. 5408
Background
When the House began its sitting on March 20, the Speaker drew attention to his serious misgivings about the procedural implications of the fourth report of the Standing Committee on Miscellaneous Estimates which had been presented the previous day. The Chair was troubled because the report appeared to go beyond the terms of the Royal Recommendation and might also complicate the timetable for supply. Prior to considering the supply day motion of March 24, arguments were presented on the matter and the Speaker made his decision.
Issue
Is a committee report acceptable if it contains an amendment to change the destination or the objects of a vote as stipulated by the Royal Recommendation?
Decision
No. The report of the committee is a nullity and no subsequent proceeding need be taken in relation to it.
Reasons given by the Speaker
"No principle is more surely provided for by our constitution and our Standing Orders than that which provides that the Crown alone initiates financial proposals . . . It is not competent . . . for the House or any committee of this House to substitute a financial provision in an estimate for one which has been recommended by His Excellency."
Sources cited
Standing Order 62(1).
Beauchesne, 4th ed., p. 205, c. 244(3); p. 207, c. 246(3).
References
Journals, March 19, 1970, pp. 615-6; March 20, 1970, p. 619.
Debates, March 19, 1970, p. 5211; March 20, 1970, p. 5269; March 23, 1970, p. 5345; March 24, 1970, pp. 5405-9.