Skip to main content

HESA Committee Report

If you have any questions or comments regarding the accessibility of this publication, please contact us at accessible@parl.gc.ca.

PDF

Appendix A: Photographs of Breast Implant Complications

 

WARNING: This appendix contains images with partial nudity and graphic medical content.

Patient advocates have recommended that Health Canada include photographs showing the complications of breast implants on its website to increase awareness of potential adverse effects and improve informed consent. Figures A1 through A10 provide a selection of such photographs.

Figure A1—Swollen Left Breast in a Patient with Breast Implant-Associated Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (BIA-ALCL)

A photograph of a nude woman’s torso. The woman’s left breast is swollen.

Note:      The patient’s left breast is swollen. One of the main symptoms of BIA-ALCL is persistent swelling around the breast implant.[1]

Source: Photo courtesy of the Breast Implant Failure & Illness Society – Canada, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A2—Syringes Filled with Seroma from a Patient Diagnosed with BIA‑ALCL

A photograph of seven syringes and a laboratory specimen container on a grey surface. The syringes and container are filled with a light brown liquid.

Note:      Patients with BIA-ALCL often have an accumulation of fluid (seroma) around the breast implant.[2]

Source: Photo courtesy of the Breast Implant Failure & Illness Society – Canada, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A3—Mass Found in Capsule of Patient with Stage 4 BIA-ALCL

A photograph of a reddish mass in a small metal bowl. Surrounding the mass are what appear to be an explanted scar tissue capsule and some gel from a breast implant. Part of the breast implant is on a surface next to the metal bowl.

Note:      Lumps around the breast or armpit can be a sign of BIA-ALCL.[3]

Source: Photo courtesy of the Breast Implant Failure & Illness Society – Canada, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A4—Ruptured Cohesive Silicone Gel (“Gummy Bear”) Breast Implants

A photograph showing a person with gloved hands lifting two ruptured breast implants, one in each hand. The material from the implants appears sticky and stretches as it is lifted. The implants are in front of the person, on a surface covered in blue cloth. In front of the implants, on the same surface, are two scar tissue capsules labelled left and right.

Note:      Rupture is a possible complication of both saline and silicone implants.

Source: Photo courtesy of Dr. Aditya Sood, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A5—Rupture of Poly Implant Prothèse (PIP) Breast Implant

A photograph of a surgical procedure. A patient lies on an operating table with torso exposed. The patient has an opening in the skin where the left breast implant has been removed. A surgeon uses metal surgical tools to lift up the tissue under the left breast to show silicone in the patient’s body following implant rupture. A hand in the foreground holds a white gauze, on top of which rests the shell of the ruptured implant.

Note:     Silicone implants manufactured by the French company Poly Implant Prothèse (PIP) were removed from the market after health authorities in France discovered they contained industrial‑grade rather than medical-grade silicone and were more prone to rupture.[4] Although PIP implants were never distributed in Canada, patients in Canada may have received them while abroad.

Source: Photo courtesy of Dr. Stephen Nicolaidis, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A6—Silicone Granulomas

A photograph showing a close-up image of a gloved hand. On the fingers of the hand rest five silicone granulomas. They are small, irregularly shaped, and yellowy-brown in colour.

Note:      Silicone granuloma formation may occur following extracapsular rupture of a breast implant (i.e., when silicone escapes beyond the capsule around the implant). There have been reports of silicone granulomas found in numerous sites throughout patients’ bodies.[5]

Source: Photo courtesy of the Breast Implant Failure & Illness Society – Canada, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A7—Debris in a 23-Year-Old Saline Breast Implant

A photograph of two breast implants and two scar capsules on a blue cloth. The left implant is bright yellow and has marks indicating debris. In contrast, the right implant is mostly transparent.

Source: Photo courtesy of Dr. Aditya Sood, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A8—Smooth Saline Implants Recalled Because of Valve Issue

This figure is a composite of four photographs. The top left image shows two breast implants, each covered in a reddish scar capsule. The bottom left image shows two breast implants that appear to be partially depleted of saline. The top right image shows a single breast implant that has discolouration on a part of its surface. The bottom right image shows a different angle of the same implant, with a closer view of the discolouration on the surface.

Note:      The top left image shows implants in scar capsules. The bottom left image shows a saline leak. The photos on the right show discolouration with possible contamination of the implant.

Source: Photo courtesy of the Breast Implant Failure & Illness Society – Canada, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A9—Grade IV Capsular Contracture

A photograph of two breast implants on a white surface. Both are covered in a scar tissue capsule that appears thick and hard. The left implant has an opening in the capsule through which a whitish grey substance can be seen.

Note:      Capsular contracture refers to the tightening or hardening of scar tissue around the implant. The severity of capsular contracture is graded on a scale from I to IV, with I representing the least severe (asymptomatic) and IV representing the most severe (hard, misshapen and/or painful breasts).[6]

Source: Photo courtesy of Dr. Stephen Nicolaidis, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.

Figure A10—Heavily Calcified 30-Year-Old Breast Implants

A photograph of two breast implants on a blue surface, with their corresponding scar capsules above them. The scar capsules are opened to show beige calcium deposits on the inner surface. The surface of both breast implants is also coated with a beige substance.

Note:      Calcium deposits can form on the breast implant capsule. Calcification can interfere with breast cancer screening.[7]

Source: Photo courtesy of Dr. Aditya Sood, submitted to the committee by Nancy Pratt.


[1]                  United States Food and Drug Administration, Questions and Answers about Breast Implant-Associated Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (BIA-ALCL).

[2]                  United States Food and Drug Administration, Questions and Answers about Breast Implant-Associated Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (BIA-ALCL).

[3]                  United States Food and Drug Administration, Questions and Answers about Breast Implant-Associated Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (BIA-ALCL).

[4]                  France 24, French PIP breast implants: an ongoing global health scandal, 29 September 2018.

[5]                  Hanad Ahmed et al., “Chest Wall Silicone Granuloma Following Ruptured Silicone Breast Implant Causes Giant Chest Wall Abscess and Osteomyelitis: The First Report,” European Journal of Breast Health, Vol. 17, No. 4, October 2021.

[6]                  Kevin Tehrani, “What is capsular contracture and how can it be treated?,” American Society of Plastic Surgeons, 12 June 2018.

[7]                  United States Food and Drug Administration, Risks and Complications of Breast Implants.