Selected Decisions of Speaker Peter Milliken 2001 - 2011

Appendix — 38th Parliament Chronological Table

38th Parliament, 1st Session
Date Chapter Decision
November 15, 2004 The Legislative Process Stages
Report stage: power of the Speaker to select amendments; opportunity for amendments to have been presented in committee
November 18, 2004 Private Members’ Business Financial Limitation
Establishment of first Order of Precedence: Speaker’s statement regarding royal recommendation
November 23, 2004 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of the House
Freedom from obstruction, interference, intimidation and molestation: usurpation of the title “Member of Parliament”; prima facie
December 1, 2004 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of Members
Freedom from obstruction, interference, intimidation and molestation: Members denied access to the Parliamentary Precinct during visit of the President of the United States; prima facie
December 14, 2004 Private Members’ Business Similar Items
Private Members’ Bills: identical items on the Order Paper
March 8, 2005 Rules of Debate Order and Decorum
Prime Minister alleged to have deliberately misled the House
March 21, 2005 Private Members’ Business Financial Limitation
Royal recommendations: not required for a bill that negotiates an agreement for redress
March 22, 2005 Special Debates Address in Reply to the Speech from the Throne
Alleged contempt of the House: Prime Minister accused of not respecting the amendment to the Address
March 23, 2005 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of the House
Contempt of the House: Government alleged to have disregarded Parliament
April 12, 2005 The Daily Program Daily Proceedings
Oral Questions: administrative responsibility of the Government; internal matters of a political party
April 20, 2005 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of Members
Freedom of speech: sub judice convention; statements by a Member regarding another Member under criminal investigation
May 3, 2005 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of the House
Contempt of the House: Prime Minister alleged to have disregarded a decision of the House concerning an Order in Council appointment
May 3, 2005 Rules of Debate Order and Decorum
References to Members: dispute as to facts
May 4, 2005 The Daily Program Daily Proceedings
Oral Questions: Minister tabling a document
May 5, 2005 The House and Its Members Miscellaneous
Concurrence in a committee report: considering the same question twice
May 13, 2005 The Daily Program Routine Proceedings
Motions: Standing Order 56.1; disposition of Government bills
May 19, 2005 The Daily Program Daily Proceedings
Oral Questions: questions concerning matters before committees; used by Members of the opposition to comment on committee business
May 31, 2005 Rules of Debate Order and Decorum
Unparliamentary language: general accusations
June 7, 2005 The Daily Program Daily Proceedings
Oral Questions: Members’ power to discuss matters currently under investigation by Ethics Commissioner
June 8, 2005 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of Members
Freedom from obstruction, interference, intimidation and molestation: third parties blocking Members’ fax lines and registering Internet domain names associated with Members
June 14, 2005 Rules of Debate Order and Decorum
References to Members: dispute as to facts; impugning motives; personal attacks
June 20, 2005 Private Members’ Business Financial Limitation
Senate bill: infringement on the financial initiative of the Crown
June 21, 2005 The House and Its Members Miscellaneous
Business of the House: notice requirement for Government motion during late night sittings
June 21, 2005 Special Debates Emergency Debates
Leave granted: Devils Lake diversion project; timing of the debate determined by unanimous consent
June 23, 2005 The Decision-making Process Miscellaneous
Recorded divisions: casting vote
September 26, 2005 The House and Its Members Miscellaneous
Business of Supply: formula for determining allotted days
September 26, 2005 Special Debates Emergency Debates
Leave refused: gasoline prices; debate held by unanimous consent
September 29, 2005 Rules of Debate Process of Debate
Motions: amendment; beyond the scope
October 3, 2005 The Daily Program Daily Proceedings
Statements by Members: singing
October 6, 2005 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of the House
Contempt of the House: Officers of Parliament; Ethics Commissioner’s actions and remarks regarding an investigation of a Member; prima facie
October 6, 2005 Rules of Debate Process of Debate
Motions: amendment; relevance; within the scope
October 7, 2005 The Daily Program Daily Proceedings
Oral Questions: administrative responsibility of the Government; Speaker’s statement regarding questions about the transfer of election campaign funds
October 20, 2005 The Daily Program Daily Proceedings
Oral Questions: Member’s conflict of interest
November 15, 2005 Parliamentary Privilege Rights of Members
Freedom of speech: sub judice convention; question on the Order Paper left unanswered because the matter was before the courts

For questions about parliamentary procedure, contact the Table Research Branch

Top of page